By licensing escort
agencies, which are commonly
known to provide sex for
money, the City of Calgary
led an escort operator to
believe he wasn't breaking
any laws, Court of Queen's
Bench Justice Patrick
Sullivan ruled Tuesday.
Douglas Eastaugh, 40, had
faced 15 charges relating to
running Liaisons Escort
Agency in 2002 and 2003.
The owner of a rival city
escort service said the
judge's decision will allow
her to conduct business with
more confidence.
"This is fantastic," said
Carol, who owns The Sweetest
Taboo and refused to give
her last name or age. "This
is going to allow me to be a
little more confident about
running my business.
"I feel like we're doing
nothing wrong in this
industry. There are a lot of
lonely, lonely people who
need company."
Eastaugh was found guilty
of two counts of living off
the avails of prostitution,
one count of operating a
common bawdy house and one
count of using a cellphone
when he was prohibited by
the courts.
But Eastaugh was not
sentenced to a prison term.
"The City of Calgary
erroneously induced the
accused to reasonably
believe that deriving an
income from an escort
agency, where escorts are
engaged in sex for money,
was not contrary to the
criminal law," Sullivan
said, delivering his 81-page
verdict.
He cited a 1995 letter
from a police commissioner
urging the mayor to repeal
the bylaw, which was "a
thinly veiled attempt to
control prostitution." A
commissioner's report said
the licensing served to
"legitimize a portion of the
sex trade industry."
Sullivan discharged the
charge of violating a court
order prohibiting cellphone
use.
The only sentence
Eastaugh received was for
operating a bawdy house,
relating to women having sex
with clients in his home. In
that case, the approximately
250 days he served before
trial fulfilled the
sentence.
Defence lawyer Patrick
Fagan was thrilled Eastaugh
was freed.
He said his client
believed he was shielded
from prosecution by being
licensed by the city.
"The city tried to do the
right thing," Fagan said.
"They tried to get the girls
off the street. They tried
to make things safer,
cleaner. They simply
legislated in an area in
which they have no
jurisdiction."
The family of a
26-year-old escort who
committed suicide while
meeting clients in Vancouver
was numbed by news that
Eastaugh wouldn't return to
jail.
"I think the bylaw should
be changed. . . . (The city)
takes money from agencies
that provide escorts and
prostitutes," said the
cousin of the escort, who
cannot be named under a
publication ban.
The escort's mother also
wants the bylaw rewritten.
"As a mom, I don't want
to see this happen to
another family. Another
young woman who is put in a
vulnerable place and makes a
wrong decision (could) pay
with her life or her
family's life," she said,
her fingers touching a round
button with her daughter's
face on it.
The Crown is reviewing
the verdict and hasn't
decided whether to seek an
appeal, said prosecutor
David Torske.
Meanwhile, Torske is
concerned about the effect
the decision could have on
Calgary's illegal sex trade.
"It may give a green
light to the operating of
escort services and
(legalize) the business of
prostitution in this city,"
he said.
Officials of the City of
Calgary and Calgary Police
Services declined to comment
while an appeal is possible.
But the city's date and
escort bylaw remains in
effect "and will continue to
be enforced as required,"
said Stan Schwartzenberger,
manager of the city's
development and business
licence department.
Mahfooz Kanwar, a
criminologist at Mount Royal
College, said Tuesday's
decision could be used to
legitimize escort services
across Canada, setting a
precedent for cities with
similar bylaws.
It could also be used by
other Calgary escort
services facing prostitution
charges, or deter the Crown
from bringing charges in the
first place, he added.
"Obviously the City of
Calgary has to strengthen
the bylaw immediately. A
judge has ruled the law we
have in place now
essentially legalizes
prostitution in escort
services," he said.
The Sweetest Taboo's
Carol said she's a
"dinosaur" in the escort
business, having obtained
her first business licence
in Calgary in 1993.
She said it's difficult
to determine what happens
between her escorts and her
clients behind closed doors,
but maintained her service
isn't about sex.
"When I send somebody
out, or when I go myself, to
the Westin or the Palliser
and I'm sitting in a room,
hey, the sky's the limit,"
she said. "Where's the harm
in it?"
*** note *** This is a
general and descriptive
explaination of Canadian
Escorts laws, but for more
info, consult a lawyer for
case law and clarifications
or terms. Ottawa Escort and
Escorts law: this article
has been included in
OttawaAtNight.com and its
other network of At Night
Escort Sites by request. I
hope it answers all your
questions.